0

Are both of these sentences correct? Which is better?

  • Select a directory to sync with.
  • Select a directory with which to sync.

From my point of view, the 1st version is better. It's mine.

The 2nd one is an abridged version of the sentence from Scrivener (an app for writers):

  • Choose a folder with which to sync files from this project.

I believe that in its original form this sentence is OK, but in its abridged form it sounds weird to me, for some reason. I assume that such "acoustic weirdness" is a signal that the sentence is in error.

1

Both of those sentences are fine in the grammar department.

Long ago there used to be a "rule" (or so some people thought) that one should never put a preposition (like "with") at the end of any sentence. I do not know for sure whether such a rule ever existed, but many people have heard about it.

According to many answers I have read on this site (ell.stackexchange), if such a rule ever existed, it doesn't apply today, and it is now perfectly OK to end a sentence in "with" if you want to. In any case, people fluent in English do it a lot.

In formal highly educated writing, it is common to use the phrase "[preposition] which" to avoid that preposition winding up as the last word in the sentence.

Examples:

1) "Select a directory with which to sync."

&

2) "My uncle wrote the book from which she is going to read."

instead of:

1) "Select a directory to sync with."

&

2) "My uncle wrote the book she is going to read from."

The first pair of sentences are written in a very educated, formal style. Both of them are grammatically correct, but that kind of phrasing is not usually heard in casual conversation. Most native English speakers would choose the second type of sentence structure for speech or informal writing.

But both of the sentences you mention are correct.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.