1

Jacob is sleeping in bed. His phone, which is on silent mode, is ringing silently on the nightstand. He instinctively wakes up, sees it's ringing, and picks up.

Hi, everyone. Is "instinctively" the best word here or would "intuitively" be better?

Also, would you write it "He instinctively wakes up" or "He wakes up instinctively"?

0

Both words are synonymous, but there might be a bit more intelligence implied by the word intuition.

"Instinct" literally applies to non-learned behaviours. Animals are governed by instinct far more than humans are, born with sometimes highly complex behaviours such as migration patterns. Most things considered human "instincts" are just survival reflexes. Instincts are also usually fixed patterns of behaviour that do not allow for free thought. Of course, the word is used in a broader, figurative way to describe human behaviours or choices which seemed correct perhaps because of transferrable knowledge or skills, which does imply some level of learned skill or intelligence.

"Intuition" involves applying logic and intelligence to a new situation. For example, computer operating systems are sometimes described as "intuitive", meaning that someone who has never seen it before should find it easy to use because it is designed in a logical or perhap familiar way. Although the word does mean the ability to do something without relying on too much thought or skill, it implies a little more intelligence than "instinct", and is perhaps more synonymous with what some people call "common sense".

For your example, I would use "instinct". Waking up to an alarm or some other sound meant to wake us, when we perhaps sleep through other ambient sounds, is very much an instinctive response.

As an aside, you may also want to look up pavlovian responses, which are a "learned" response to a particular stimulus (eg an alarm sound), although I don't think it would fit your example without considerable adjustment.

  • I once read that naturalists discarded the idea of 'instinct' around 1930. – Michael Harvey Nov 20 at 22:34
  • @MichaelHarvey It briefly fell from favour because of a rising interest in psychology and learned behaviours, but then it was picked it up again in the 1950s when clearer distinctions arose between instinct and learned behaviour. It is still taught in schools. – Astralbee Nov 21 at 9:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy