0

Can I use the sentence "have you got an umbrella" or anything else to ask someone whether he got it or not?

2
  • Your question is unclear, can you explain what you mean? "Have you got an umbrella" means the same as to "Do you have an umbrella". Does this answer your question?
    – 79037662
    Dec 9 '19 at 19:17
  • Suppose i have lost my umbrella and i can't find it anywhere so can i use this sentence - have you got my umbrella anywhere Dec 10 '19 at 8:20
1

"Do you have an umbrella?" can mean "do you own an umbrella?" or "do you have an umbrella with you right now?"

"Did you get an umbrella?" means "did you buy an umbrella?" (or get one as a gift or borrow one or steal one or however you might come to have one). That is, it is asking about the act of acquiring an umbrella, rather than simply having one.

If you asked someone, "Did you get an umbrella?", and he's had the same umbrella for 20 years, he might well say, "No, I already have one." Because he didn't get another, he's still using the one he already had. "Did you get ..." implies "recently", though there's no set period of time. It depends on context.

2

I think you are asking whether this can be about whether the person has acquired an umbrella, or only about whether they currently have one.

I can only answer for British English - I think the answer would not be the same for American English, where they mostly prefer Do you have to Have you; and use gotten for the past participle of get.

Here, there is no reason in principle why Have you got an umbrella? should not be a question about whether you went to get one; but because it is so common in the meaning of possession, it is unlikely to be used in that way. Far more likely are Did you get an umbrella? or Have you been to get an umbrella?

4
  • I think you are correct. "Have you got an umbrella?" is meaning-identical to "Do you have an umbrella?" in American English. The answer would never be "Yes, but I left it at home!" - that sounds like the person speaking is a little bit crazy (or British! :) )
    – BadZen
    Dec 9 '19 at 20:35
  • @ManishkumarKumar: your comment is nothing to do with this question: it just happens to use the word got. Please, if you want to ask a new question ask a new question, don't do so in a comment. But I'll answer: those sentences are perfectly normal, and feature the colloquial use of get to form a non-static passive.
    – Colin Fine
    Dec 30 '19 at 10:19
  • Thank you,Coline Fine Dec 30 '19 at 12:15
  • Please answer.... Dec 30 '19 at 15:40

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.