1

_______ (visit) your aunt while you are in Paris?

I think the answers can be:

  • Will you be visiting

  • Will you visit

  • Are you going to visit.

What about the present continuous, Are you visiting. Is it possible here? If yes, what does it mean in this case?

2
  • 2
    The present progressive here means the same thing as the others. This is the present progressive futurate, i.e.,the tense is present, the aspect is progressive, but the verb refers to the future. You can also say, "Do you visit your aunt while you are in Paris?" with a repetitive meaning, i.e., "Do you always visit your aunt...."
    – user105719
    Dec 19 '19 at 9:18
  • @user105719 you should post that as an actual answer
    – cjl750
    Dec 21 '19 at 23:50
1
+50

Strictly speaking, these questions have different meanings and occasions in which should be used (usage patterns). In practice people often use them interchangeably, and the meaning is inferred from the context. English is a living language and therefore it is dynamic - the "rules" sometimes done reflect actual use... but they are the rules.

I'm using examples from the Education First (EF) English grammar web pages.

The precise usage patterns are:

Will you be visiting your aunt while you are in Paris?

When discussing a plan to be in Paris at a known future time; does the plan include visiting your aunt (staying with her for some time)?

The question uses future continuous tense/aspect, which is used for several purposes; The EF page includes the statement: "The future continuous refers to an unfinished action or event that will be in progress at a time later than now". But it also mentions that "In the interrogative form, the future continuous can be used to ask politely for information about the future".

Are you visiting your aunt while you are in Paris?

This sentence is in Present continuous. The usual interpretation would be a discussion about the present. It could be either

  • You are currently in Paris and the question is about whether you are also currently visiting your aunt
  • You are going to Paris regularly (e.g. every year in June, starting in the past and continuing into the future) and the question is about whether you have a habit of visiting your aunt when you are there.

As stated in EF, present continuous can also "describe an action or event in the future, which has already been planned or prepared". But this is usually done by adding some time description like "next week". In this case there is no hint that it discusses the future, so it is not a likely interpretation. For discussing a future plan, use "will you be visiting" or "are you going to visit".

-- edit - additional information on future simple --

I was asked in the comment about using future simple "Will you visit...". The "Simple future tense" EF page states that

With you in the interrogative form, to give an invitation: Will you come to the dance with me? Will you marry me?

However. I'd say this is a very strict prescription; people use "will you" in interrogation (questions) in many other cases too, and the meaning is often clear from the context. If you were to ask me "Will you visit your aunt while you are in Paris" I would understand it as a question about my plan.

If you want to be really precise in your expressions, you may choose to avoid "will you" in this case.

Note that the "Future" EF page nicely summarizes the attitude attached to each of the forms used for discussing the future.

3
  • 2
    But if it has already been established that you are going to visit Paris, then there is more than a "hint that it discusses the future", and it is a perfectly likely interpretation. This is one of the reasons why I maintain that there is no such thing as future tense in English. Every verb form that may refer to future time may have other meanings as well.
    – Colin Fine
    Dec 24 '19 at 19:45
  • Could you please tell me if "Will you visit" is correct and what it means in this case?
    – Helen
    Dec 28 '19 at 7:45
  • "will" conveys intention, you are the person who decides whether you are going to visit or not.
    – anouk
    Dec 29 '19 at 16:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.