0

I want to make a question sentence like the below "Is calling a taxi is the only way to take a taxi here? (Or from here?)"

  • and wonder if 'calling for a taxi" would mean same as "calling a taxi".

  • Also, would it have any slight difference if I use 'from here' instead of just 'here' at the end of the sentence?

1
  • The specific example about 'call for' is helpful to understtand its meaning. + Umm.. "Do I need to call a taxi here?" already contains the meaning of 'the only way to take a taxi is to call it' ? – longne Jan 1 '20 at 20:41
1

While both expressions are idiomatic, call a taxi is far more common, as illustrated in the Google Books Ngram Viewer below.

The expression call for is generally used in the sense of required. To say that this calls for a taxi means that a taxi will be required - as opposed to a bus or a bicycle for example.

If you needed to make a phone call to get a taxi, you might also say: I need to call for a taxi, meaning to make a call for a taxi. But the use of for is optional here.

Note that your sentence is repetitive and awkward: People would not say: Is calling a taxi is the only way to take a taxi here?. Rather just: Do we need/have to call a taxi (here)? Or, Should we call a taxi (here)?

The use of from here implies from this point, as though you have walked a certain distance and now require a taxi to continue your journey. Just here simply means to your location.

https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=call+a+taxi%

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.