1

Online dictionaries say that I can call a place gloomy that is dark, or badly lit 'in a way that makes me feel depressing'. I think this part is important, isn't it?

Let's say I am in a place that is completely dark or not very well lit, but it does not make me feel frightened in any way. I can't use the adjective gloomy to describe the place, can I?

2

The words "gloom," "gloaming," and "gloomy" seem to have an obscure etymology. According to the Online Etymological Dictionary, it seems to have originally been a word referring to the half-light of dusk.

Nowadays, it can still be used to refer to physical darkness without any necessary emotional connotation.

Even with the light on, the corners of the cellar are gloomy.

Obviously, a cellar cannot be emotionally depressed.

However, the word has also been associated for centuries with melancholy and thus frequently has emotional connotations that have nothing to do physical light.

He has been gloomy ever since his divorce.

This does not imply that he has not been in the sunshine since his divorce.

But sometimes the word is used to indicate the emotional effect of what is phyically dark.

He shuddered gloomily as entered the shadowed interior of the crypt

Here it would be natural to to interpret the sentence as explicitly referring to an emotion caused by a diminution of physical light.

In short, there is a meaning that is completely physical, another that is completely emotional, and a third that combines those senses. Which meaning is intended depends on context.

1
  • Thanks a lot. Very thorough and helpful!
    – 4d_
    Feb 21 '20 at 5:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.