1

He robbed a woman just hours earlier.

He robbed a woman of her bag.

Why not say "He robbed a woman her bag"? Why should "of" be used here?

Likewise, it seems that the usage of "fine" is similar to

He fined the woman $ 100.

Why not say "He fined the woman of $100"?

  • 1
    No reason. It's just an arbitrary requirement imposed by the English language. – snailcar May 21 '14 at 6:36
1

Because that's the structure. You always rob somebody/something OF something

rob - to steal money or property from a person or place

So, it's He robbed a woman of her bag.

Likewise, you always fine somebody something FOR something/doing something

fine - fine somebody something

So, it could be - He fined the woman $100 for breaking the traffic rule.

  • It's usually good practice not to use the word you're defining in the definition. Although, to be fair, it's more of a predicate-argument syntax than a definition. You can also just rob somebody, without specifying what it was, a la: she robbed him, I was robbed, etc. Similarly you can fine someone without specifying the amount: He was fined. – jimsug May 21 '14 at 6:08
  • @jimsug No! That's not the OP is concerned about. I think everybody knows that she robbed him is a complete sentence. The OP specifically asked how/why preposition 'of' is used. And, I used it could be in my last sentence and included the preposition to make the point clearer. – Maulik V May 21 '14 at 6:19
  • 1
    Yeah, sorry - got carried away with syntax. But my point about definitions stands. Just because something in your answer isn't what the OP asks for specifically, doesn't mean it shouldn't be well-formed. – jimsug May 21 '14 at 6:23
  • @jimsug you again missed it! I specifically typed the standard use of prepositions in 'preformatted text' and did not include them as definitions. In fact, if you want well-formed sentence, I think everybody will strongly prefer going for the structure defined in OALD. :) – Maulik V May 21 '14 at 6:58
  • Okay,using exclamation marks makes you sound defensive. I apologise for thinking that you were defining the words using quote formatting. Clearly, I misunderstood. – jimsug May 21 '14 at 7:10

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.