0

Doing some tasks in the textbook I stumbled across one sentence. Here is a small dialog.

Do you have a headache ?

Yes, I've had a headache all morning.

Why do we use the present perfect tense here, but not the pres. perf. continuous ? My logic is that we have an indicator for a period of time (all morning) and have is a part of the set phrase (have a headache), which is the reason why have can be used in continuous context. But still, we use the present perfect tense. Although I've been having a headache all morning sounds weird for me. Where am I wrong?

  • What does that small dialog do? In other words, what is the task? – WXJ96163 Mar 31 at 22:50
1

The verb "have" already provides the "continuous" sense. It describes a state, and not an action

So we tend to say

I have a headache.

and not

(?) I am having a headache.

(This latter in grammatically correct, but sounds odd. As if is something the speaker can turn off if they chose)

So when we put that into a perfect form (to describe the state starting at some time in the past) No continuous tense is used.

You could use a continuous tense for repeated headaches over a period of time

I've been having headaches once or twice a week for the last six months.

| improve this answer | |
  • Ok, thanks It's clear for me now – DenVys Mar 31 at 21:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.