0

You said, "My Son, I live for you".

I want to know if it is absolutely necessary that the speaker is the son. And how do you change the sentence to indirect speech.

1
  • The speaker could be anyone. Start the sentence 'You said to me...' and it could only be the son speaking, or else the other person could be a priest or older person or wise man, etc, speaking to a younger, where 'my son' was, at one time a customary form of address – Michael Harvey Apr 11 '20 at 8:43
0

The speaker could be anyone. If Joe, Pete and Pete's son, Harry are in a room

Pete: My son, I live for you.
Joe (to Pete): You said, "My son, I live for you".
Harry (to Pete): I agree. You said, "My son, I live for you".
Pete: I know what I said! I said, "My son, I live for you." You don't need to repeat everything I say, already!

If Joe was reporting this he might say:

Pete told his son that he lived/lives for him.

(This has pronoun ambiguity)

And Harry might report

Dad told me that he lived/lives for me. What a weird thing to say!

And Pete might report

I told Harry that I lived/live for him. I hoped to have a moment, but him and Pete ruined it by just repeating me like strange robots. What's up with that?

Backshifting is, as usual, optional.

0

Yes - anyone can quote anyone verbatim. When they do, they normally make it absolutely clear that they are doing so. There are a number of ways they may do this verbally; in writing, the quotation marks serve the purpose. I can find no fault with your example.

It is probably more common for someone to state the meaning of what someone said than to quote them verbatim, for example:

Father: My son, I live for you.
Son: You said that you live for me.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.