0

Given answer in book is (E) "No Error". But there is a rule in textbook that we can't use article before the noun which comes after "Each / Every / Each and Every / Either / Neither". Can anybody help in understanding the answer?

2
  • Possibly the creator of the question is not a native English speaker. .... ten captains each had an... is more natural. And I don't like the use of his and would say their because of the multiple captains.
    – user19179
    Commented Apr 16, 2020 at 12:44
  • The answer is correct, but the use of "his" assumes that all of the captains are male, which may not be true, (unless there is additional context not included here). Commented Mar 6 at 16:26

1 Answer 1

0

There is no error. What is in error is the rule in your text book or your interpretation of the rule.

In the passage provided, the meaning is

Each of the ten capitains had an achievment of his own.

Notice that "each" refers to "captains," and "captains" has a definite article associated with it. For emphasis, you may also say

The ten captains each had an achievement of his own

The ten captains had each an achievement of his own

although the second is very rare.

What is not rare is

Each captain had an achievement of his own.

What all these examples share is that "each" refers to individual members of a group of capitains, not their individual achievements.

What you cannot grammatically say is

Each the ten captains had ...

The rule is that if "each" precedes the noun to which "each" applies, it cannot be immediately followed by an article applying to the same noun. Moreover, that rule does not apply to "either" or "neither.

Either the man or the boy can do it because each knows the password

Neither the man nor the boy can do it because neither one knows the password.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .