5

How often is a whistle blower used as a derogatory term? Can one say "I don't want to blow the whistle, I am not this kind of a man."

  • I would say that the term usually implies that the "whistle blower" went against some fashion of authority to "blow the whistle", so to speak. – Pockets May 31 '14 at 16:42
6

This is an interesting question because I think it's going to hit a bias in ELL.SE user demographics.

The expression to blow the whistle means to expose corruption, that is, conspiracy or extortion by means of state power or state-backed corporate power.

So what you feel about whistleblowers has an awful lot to do with how you feel about state power.

ELL.SE users draw very heavily from the tech trades, and, at least in the US, that is a population that tends toward having negative feelings about state power, or who are at least very touchy about how state power is used. I count myself in this cohort. On top of that, the Snowden revelations have primed a lot of people already skeptical about abuses of power to feel very negatively indeed about it. Among this population whistle blowing is seen as something heroic.

It can be hard for those of us in this demographic to realize there is also a sizable demographic in the US which is very authoritarian in both personality and culture. They actually think authority and systems of authority are good things, and that people who challenge authority are immoral. For them whistleblower is a negative term and blowing the whistle means something very like betrayal. At best, if a whistleblower is vindicated subsequently, people with such sympathies to authority tend to see the whistleblower as, at best, a "necessary evil", and someone of low character who happened to be right -- like a criminal who turned on other criminals. These are the people saying, "Even if Snowden was right, he had no right to do what he did."

(This is sort of off topic, but if you're interested in this sort of thing in US culture, you may want to check on The Authoritarians by Altmeyer, "Red Family, Blue Family" by Muder, Red Families v. Blue Families by Cahn and Carbone, and the work of Jonathan Haidt on morality across cultures (somebody else's paraphrase here, his TED talk here)).

As to the valence of blow the whistle in any other English-speaking culture, I can't speak.

  • I think this is an excellent answer, because it really does depend on your point of view (and different people might even have different opinions on each case of whistle-blowing). I think this is the best answer, because it's very true that this could go either way. +1! – WendiKidd May 31 '14 at 19:03
  • Whenever someone "blows the whistle," there's potential for one group of people to go to jail, and another group of people to be glad those folks will be getting the justice that they deserve. How you perceive the whistleblower, then, might depend on which side of the bars you're on. – J.R. Jun 1 '14 at 1:44
3

Blow the whistle simply means tell people publicly something bad that someone is doing. Whistle-blower in itself is not derogatory.

  • This is interesting: if you tell people publicly about someone doing something bad, I think they're doing something good. Alternately, I wonder whether you could blow the whistle on someone doing something good. – jimsug May 31 '14 at 12:46
  • @jimsug, how about "Dangit! I knew he was going to blow the whistle on the [surprise] party plans." – Pockets May 31 '14 at 16:39
  • 1
    @jimsug no; just saying of something that the whistle was blown on it implies you think it is legally or ethically wrong. You can use the term ironically, but if you do, expect it to be taken as only slightly covert hostility. – Codeswitcher May 31 '14 at 17:29
-4

I don't think it is always negative. And yes, blow the whistle phrase is possible which means you let others know something is happening or happened which is unethical or bad.

The alert residents blew the whistle on thieves by calling the cops before they could rob anything.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.