0

An English class use this as the topic for students.

What social problems exist in big cities

enter image description here

Typically, to construct a wh-question, one needs to use an auxiliary verb, such as "do/does", which the quoted sentence doesn't have one. So, is the sentence grammatically correct?

3
  • 1
    Typically, to construct a question, one needs to use an auxiliary verb, such as "do/does." Really? Are you sure? First, typically doesn't mean always. But, that aside, where have you learned this as a rule? Commented May 25, 2020 at 0:56
  • @JasonBassford dictionary.cambridge.org/grammar/british-grammar/…
    – JJJohn
    Commented May 25, 2020 at 1:16
  • Ah! It makes more sense with that edit. Commented May 25, 2020 at 1:38

2 Answers 2

3

The rule "to construct a question, one needs to use an auxiliary verb, such as 'do/does'" does not apply when what is being asked is the subject, because, if what is asked is the subject, it is obviously not possible to have subject-auxiliary inversion (where would we place the auxiliary if the subject is in front position?).

Therefore, questions asking for the subject and introduced by who, what, which, whose, how much/many are followed by the verb as it will appear in the answer:

  • What social problems exist in big cities?
  • Problems such as pollution, crime and unemployment exist in big cities.

  • Which represents the worst problem?

  • Pollution represents the worst problem.

  • How many poeople live in big cities?

  • Millions of people people live in big cities.

  • Who lives in a big city?

  • I live in a big city.

By the way, in the source you just quoted you can read:

Warning:

When what, who, which or whose is the subject or part of the subject, we do not use the auxiliary. We use the word order subject + verb:

What fell off the wall? Which horse won? Who bought this? Whose phone rang?

0

(1) When wh-word is the subject or part of the subject of the question,

Wh-word [subject] + verb

e.g., [Who] wrote 'The Merchant of Venice'?

[What social problems] exist in big cities?

The bracketed part is the subject.

(2) When wh-word is not the subject,

Wh-word + Auxiliary verb + Subject + Main Verb ...

e.g., What do you want?

(Subject = You, Verb = want, Object = what)

Where will you go?

(Subject = you, Verb = will go, Adverbial = Where).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .