1

Some ESL students have trouble understanding the logic of sentences starting with it, i.e. 'It is cold.' Or using 'it' as a pronoun to replace ideas in general. Usually they will start the sentence with 'That is interesting...' or 'That is a cold day.'

For instance, they have trouble with sentences like 'It is interesting that you selected that factor.' Or 'It wasn't the lighting that bothered me, it was the food.'

Any tips about how to make this clearer to them?

-1

I don't really understand why the students have less of a problem with "that" than "it". All impersonal pronouns like "this", or "those", must always refer to a thing or things previously mentioned or easily identified.

When a sentence begins with "it", it must refer to something you have already spoken about, or something apparent, such as something you are both experiencing or the conditions that you are both in.

The difference between "it" and "that" is that you would normally say "that is interesting" in response to something the other person said, or something you have just become aware of, but "it is interesting" about something you already know about or have spoken about yourself. A rule of thumb when it comes to objects is that if it is right in front of you use "it" or "this", but if you can point to it from a distance use "that". Similarly, we use an appropriate pronoun with discussion topics depending on whether we brought the topic into the discussion ourself or it it was raised by someone else.

For example:

  • I have a new car. It is red.

Here, "it" refers to the car you just mentioned.

When you say "it is cold" or "it's a nice day" without previously referring to a specific place or condition, it can only refer to the current place or condition you and your audience are experiencing.

For example:

  • It's a nice day. (today)

The only time it could be ambiguous is if you were referring to conditions such as the temperature and there was a difference between the temperature inside and outside. For example, if you were inside the house on a cold day and said "it's cold", it might not be completely clear if you mean cold outside or inside the house. Context would probably provide a clue, but I would assume they meant the immediate condition they were experiencing at the time they said it.

1
  • it could be the way I explained it. I said it is a pronoun which replaces the noun. And in the sentence It is cold, it's not so clear what it is replacing, I said it replaces 'the weather.' but I think it's a different sentence construction.
    – drivegg
    May 27 '20 at 3:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.