He is a good person and a good teacher.
He is a good person and a teacher.
Do both the sentences mean the same? Does second sentence mean that he is a good teacher or simply a teacher?
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It only takes a minute to sign up.Sign up to join this community
It is an interesting and ambiguous example. Normally the adjective would apply equally to the parts and the whole.
The Godfather is an interesting book and film.
(I infer that both the book and the film called "The Godfather" are interesting. If I wanted to suggest that the film was not interesting I would need to be explicit "... but a boring film")
But in this case "good" has two quite different meanings, and contextually has different meanings in "good person" (morally and ethically virtuous) and "good teacher" (able and skillful at teaching)
Saying "He is a good person and teacher" creates an ambiguity, since the word good can't apply equally to both nouns and it is unclear what the intention of the speaker was. I'd probably assume he was a skillful teacher, but I'd wonder if the speaker was using "weasel words" (to say actually he is a poor teacher, but tricking the listener into believing the opposite)
So to be clear, use a more precise adjective
He is a good person and a skillful teacher.
(Able, professional, competent, hard-working, clear, etc)