0

From Cambridge Dictionary

Did you have any difficulties getting here? src

She had great difficulty finding a job. src

It seems that for general(yes/no) questions, I should use "difficulty" as a plural noun and an uncountable noun for declarative sentences (statement).

Is my understanding correct?


Note: This post focuses on the comparison between plural and uncountable. So it is different from "have difficulty doing" vs. "have difficulty in doing", which is focused on the usage of preposition.

Is 'have difficulties' correct? is quite related, neither the asker nor the answerer gives a solid reference though. Besides, the answer calls uncountable noun "singular", which indicates the answerer might not be rigorous or familiar with this particular grammar point.

0

Actually, I think the discussion at "Is 'have difficulties' correct" is very pertinent, but I also think I see where your concern about countability comes from.

Look at Merriam-Webster. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/difficulty

That dictionary gives five different meanings, the primary meaning being identical to the primary meaning in the dictionary you looked at. That meaning refers to a general state, "the state of being hard to do." What is general is not plural; all specific instances are included in the general, which is necessarily singular.

The second meaning in the dictionary you looked at, a "problem," is broken down into four more specific meanings in MW, but they are all types of problem, whether a disagreement, an objection, an impediment, or an embarrassment. But these specifics can be singular or plural.

My difficulty is that I have forgotten all the Latin I so painfully learned.

One difficulty is the lack of good roads; another difficulty is the lack of water, and the combination of these difficulties has reduced the district to extreme poverty.

In short, one sense of the word is necessarily singular, but the other senses of the word can be either singular or plural depending on which applies in the specific case.

A different way to think about this is that it is meanings that are countable or not countable, and, when a noun has more than one meaning, that noun may be countable in one sense but uncountable in another sense. The distinction between countable and non-countable depends on meaning.

Good question.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.