13

Let me give an example for context:

If someone posted a question here on the site and I wanted to describe them, I can say "the asker" or "the poster".

Now, if someone suggests an edit on that post, how would I describe them in a similar manner (using a single word)?

Is the word "suggester" correct? (I couldn't find any usage of it.) If it's not, I'm looking for a word that has this meaning. It doesn't have to be derived from "suggest". A synonym would suffice as long as it fits in the context (e.g., "advisor", etc. wouldn't work).


Update:

(extra info; feel free to ignore)

This post appears to have attracted a lot of people so let me try to clarify more.

The example that I used above is very similar to the real-life situation but let me include the exact context that I wanted to use it in anyway. I was trying to come up with a meaningful variable name to use in a software development project that I'm working on. The situation is as follows:

A client suggests something (actually, an edit to an existing item or a proposal for a new item) and I need to have two variables to refer to the following:

  • The client that suggested the thing.
  • The id of the client who suggested the thing.

I couldn't just use Client and ClientId because it would be ambiguous in this particular situation. I ended up using SuggestedBy and SuggestedByClientId. Although the second one isn't perfect (I think), I believe it reflects the intention pretty well. I might change it later to Proposer and ProposerClientIdas suggested by Jason in the answer below or just keep the word "proposer" in mind for future use cases.

  • 1
    I don't think there's a commonly accepted term for this. My suggestion would be to use their handle. You could also call them a commenter. – Katy Jun 12 at 3:18
  • @Katy Actually, that was just an example. It's not the real-life situation; just a very similar context. Thanks for the suggestion though (no pun intended). I accepted the fact that there isn't a single word for this so I guess I'll have to come up with an alternative way. – ICloneable Jun 12 at 5:32
  • @ICloneable Same solution though. Use their name. – the-baby-is-you Jun 12 at 7:20
  • This is context-specific. I would use editor in this particular case, but obviously that doesn't apply to other kinds of suggestions. – chrylis -cautiouslyoptimistic- Jun 12 at 14:59
  • 1
    Variable names are not really about English, Questions about computing are not a good fit for a stackexchagne about Learning English. – James K Jun 13 at 20:08
17

I have updated my answer based on several comments I've received.


Although it seems that the word suggester does actually exist as a variant of suggest (per Merriam-Webster), I find it so uncommon that, while understandable, it would give most people some pause on reading it.

I would say that a more common word is proposer.

[Merriam-Webster, propose]
1 : to form or put forward a plan or intention
// man proposes, but God disposes

Other Words from propose
proposer noun

In the right context, such as fields to be filled in on a form, the word would be quite appropriate:

Proposal: (____)

Proposer: (____)

Approved: (Yes / No)

Also, I've been informed that proposer is frequently used in formal debates.


As for comparing suggester to proposer, Google Ngram Viewer indicates that proposer is far more common, at least in print:

suggester versus proposer

As I final note, I will add that while proposer might sound strange to some, so too would asker and poster, as used in the question. Just as it would be more common to say the person who asked or the person who posted, it would also be more common to say the person who proposed (or the person who suggested). None of these single nouns are as common as a longer phrase; however, proposer is still relatively much more common than suggester.

| improve this answer | |
  • 4
    It's used quite a bit in debates, where you have a "proposal" and "proposers". As well as all sorts of rarely used expressions. – PatrickT Jun 12 at 11:01
  • Thanks, Jason! "Proposer" indeed seems to fit in the context. That being said, I just noticed that the same dictionary that you used also mentions "suggester" in the same way: Other Words from suggest --> suggester noun. Is there a reason one is correct and the other isn't? Or is it just the fact that one is used somewhat frequently and the other isn't? – ICloneable Jun 12 at 17:42
  • 1
    @ICloneable Thank you for the comment! While I had looked for suggester at Merriam-Webster, I had somehow not found it. (I can only think that I might have accidentally searched for suggestor by mistake.) In any case, I have updated my answer to make it more accurate, based on all the feedback I've been given. – Jason Bassford Jun 12 at 18:02
7

I don't know of any one English word that means "the person who made the suggestion". You have to use several words or a phrase. Like, "the person who made the suggestion".

Based on general patterns of building English words, one might think that "suggester" would be appropriate. But that's just not a word in common use. If you used it, I suppose people would easily guess what you mean, but it would definitely sound odd. If you were writing a long discussion about people who make suggestions, to avoid having to repeat a long phrase over and over you could say, "In this paper I will refer to people who make suggestions as 'suggesters'", and most readers would probably accept that. But I wouldn't use it with no explanation.

| improve this answer | |
  • (Or in a formal context at all.) – Fivesideddice Jun 13 at 12:13
4

A single, correct, commonly used and unambiguous word exists, and that word (as Jason Bassford states) is "proposer". Jason's answer does not need to be hedged around with the caveats that it is; when something has been put forward, suggested, floated, hypothesised, ventured, then if you refer to "the proposer" the average English speaker will easily understand you to mean the person who has made the suggestion. No-one will suddenly think someone is about to get married.

This would have been a comment but I'm not able to comment.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    I actually put in the caveats because the use of the word doesn't sound completely natural to me outside of certain contexts. Establishing those contexts might be simple, but they still need to be established. I also think that, more often than not in regular conversation, you would say who suggested this or who proposed this instead, because who is the proposer sounds awkward to me. Then again, who is the asker and who is the poster sound equally awkward—and the question was really just asking for an equivalent. – Jason Bassford Jun 12 at 16:41
3

A proposal is an act of submitting a structured plan of action for approval. Someone who proposes something is typically waiting for a yes/no response from an approver.

This is not quite synonymous with suggest, which means to offer an idea but not stick around to wait for approval. Hence why companies put out suggestion boxes and not proposal boxes.

Because a suggestion process doesn't involve waiting for approval, there's usually no need to link back to whoever is suggesting.

Now, if someone suggests an edit on that post, how would I describe them in a similar manner (using a single word)?

Can the edit be approved or denied? Does the person making the edit receive notice of approval or denail? Then you have a propose situation and not a suggest situation and should use the term propose instead.

| improve this answer | |
  • Ah, that makes perfect sense. Thanks for the explanation! Yes, it does require an approval (see the edit to the question for the exact context). So, do you agree with Jason that the word "proposer" is the one to use in this situation? – ICloneable Jun 12 at 17:59
  • Proposer is the word to use and the process should be renamed from suggest an edit to propose an edit. – LawrenceC Jun 12 at 18:23
  • So, StackExchange's Suggested Edits is a wrong usage? – ICloneable Jun 12 at 18:29
  • 1
    I would say inexact, and for a good reason: it makes it sound less like a formal, legal process and more like a community process, which might make people feel less bad about having it rejected. – LawrenceC Jun 12 at 18:33
3

I would put forward the following variable name; composed by Suggestion and maker. A maker is a very common noun, it refers to a person who makes something, and to "make a suggestion" is an extremely common collocation.

SuggestionMaker
IdSuggestionMaker

In written English it would probably be “suggestion maker”. Sorry, it's not a single word–although the compound noun suggestion-maker would be acceptable–its meaning remains very clear nevertheless.

I Googled, and lo and behold the term is used, with and without the hyphen.

  • The distinction between suggestion-maker and suggestion-receiver that is at work in all couples can be extrapolated to the level of the crowd.

  • If the suggestion-maker is not logged in to your website, they will see an option to log in. Any content in the suggestion text box will not be saved if the suggestion-maker is not already logged in.

  • No, I wasn't aware. I thought that the suggestion maker either didn't get to vote, or his vote was automatically considered a keep.

  • Are you a big thinker? A question asker? A suggestion maker? A life-long learner? Do you speak up when you need to and grasp opportunities in both hands?

| improve this answer | |
1

First example no one has said Editor

They attempted to edit, that became a suggested edit.

The editor's work was approved


Second example I agree with proposer, just going to add more words into the mix

Second example sounds like you have a "Improvement" object and the person who suggested it was the

submitter who submitted

creator who created

author who wrote

contributor who contributed

requestor who requested

a improvement request/change request

| improve this answer | |
  • Yes, editor, very simple. People get their knickers in a twist over the simplest things and go off on all sorts of tangents.... – Lambie Jun 16 at 18:39
0

Surprised not to see "proponent" here:

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/proponent

One who makes a proposal or proposition.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    Proponent is more commonly a person who supports a proposal – Peter Jun 14 at 5:43

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.