When one makes a choice, he is faced with some alternatives: "go by car" or "go by bus"; "prefer sightseeing" or "go shopping", "buy a house" or "rent a flat", etc. These alternatives share the same hypernym (car and bus are means of transportation; sightseeing and shopping are activities; etc) and they have the tendency to exclude each other, but how would you call their semantic relation?

Is there anything in the literature as "alternative semantic relation" or "adversarial semantic relation"?

Edit: I may have found my answer, the term what I'm looking for might be "co-hypernym" https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/9244/is-there-a-term-ending-in-nym-that-signifies-terms-that-all-have-the-same-hy?rq=1

  • What do you mean: "adversarial semantic relation"? If it means choices exclude each other, then what is the difference between it and "alternative semantic relation"? – Tang Ho Jul 1 '20 at 8:06
  • @TangHo I'm wondering if such a concept actually exists in the literature, and if it does, what it might be called? – vivasra Jul 1 '20 at 22:58
  • go by [method of transportation] is merely an idiomatic way of expressing how one moves from one place to another. There is nothing "adversarial" about it. – Lambie Jul 2 '20 at 0:00
  • 2
    I’m voting to close this question because This Linguistics question isn't about learning English – James K Apr 11 at 6:45

I would say the relationship between "go by car" (choice A) and "go by bus" (choice B) is "mutually exclusive"

Example of mutually exclusive choices:

You want to buy apple or orange first? (cannot be both at the same time. -- 'apple first' exclude 'orange first' )

Example of non-mutually exclusive choices:

Do you want to buy apple or orange? (you can buy both at the same time -- 'buy apple' doesn't exclude 'buy orange')

Another example: Fighting the pandemic doesn't exclude saving the economy (you can do both at the same time)

  • [buy apple first or orange=not very idiomatic; buy apples first or oranges] – Lambie Jul 2 '20 at 0:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.