3

1). Cambridge dictionary link and Some of my friends are saying have + object + bare infinitive is used to talk about an experience

We had a strange woman come to the door selling pictures.

2). While others are saying have + object + past participle is used to talk about an experience

We had a strange woman came to the door selling pictures.

In this site I found the second form as correct. The example I found in his site - The minister had eggs thrown at him. (This means The minister underwent the experience of eggs being thrown at him )

I feel that the first sentence means “We made or instructed a strange women come to the door” and the second sentence is correct. But as an non native speaker with zero knowledge in English, I can’t question cambridge dictionary. So which of the two is correct?

0
1

There's a confusion of types of sentences here.

There's also additional confusion because come is an irregular verb, and its past participle is not came. Its past participle is the same as its bare infinitive: come.

So:

  1. We had a woman come to the door. [bare infinitive]

    I can tell this by replacing the verb with one that is not irregular:

    We had a woman sing to the door. [bare infinitive]

  2. The minister had eggs thrown at him. [past participle]

But:

  • The minister had a woman throw eggs at him. [bare infinitive]

Note how the different sentence construction changes the verb from the past participle to the bare infinitive.

None of the example sentences at Cambridge are incorrect, and they make sense within the section of the article where they're used, but since the article doesn't mention the use of the past participle at all, I find it either incomplete or slightly confusing since they chose to use an irregular verb in one of the examples (come).

In short, I can see why it could cause trouble for some people.


A site that can be used to look up conjugations, including the past participle, for most verbs is Reverso Conjugation.

Other verbs whose past participle is the same as their bare infinitive include become, cost, cut, hit, hurt, let, put, read, run, and set.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.