2

The following is from Frankenstein by Mary Shelley; do you know what the "so to" means? It seems to mean "so as to" or "in order to", but I am not even sure if it is a unit. I can't find it in the dictionary.

Then I spurred on my animal, striving so to forget the world, my fears, and more than all, myself . . .

People might be tempted to suggest the "so" refers to the action of spurring on the animal as the means whereby the speaker could forget the world; however, consider the following:

Once again arose the voice of praise; and then followed an exhortation, full of affectionate earnestness, urging upon the disciples of Christ the duty and the privilege of striving so to enter into sympathy with Him in his agony . . . "

There is no such action as could serve as the action, whereby the disciples can enter into sympathy with Christ.

3
  • The first so means 'in order'. The second so is ambiguous--it either also means 'in order', or it could mean 'thus'--striving in the same manner as, I assume, Christ, and then the implied 'in order' is dropped entirely. In both sentences, 'to' is part of the verb and not part of a unit.
    – Kitkat
    Jul 29, 2020 at 20:04
  • But the text doesn't say how Christ strives for anything.
    – Apollyon
    Jul 30, 2020 at 2:57
  • 1
    Christ isn't striving--the disciples are being urged to strive (I would assume--the sentence is ambiguous and somewhat archaic).
    – Kitkat
    Jul 30, 2020 at 13:16

4 Answers 4

1

Then I spurred on my animal, striving so to forget the world, my fears, and more than all, myself . . .

I read this as: [striving so] + in order to. I.e., striving so much or to a great degree, and with the goal of forgetting.

In other contexts, the combination [striving so] could mean "striving in that fashion". But here, as others have pointed out, it doesn't seem to make sense. This looks like the use of "so" as a postmodifying intensifier, as in I worry so or I love you so.

urging upon the disciples of Christ the duty and the privilege of striving so to enter into sympathy with Him in his agony . . .

I read this as: striving so as to enter.... I.e. striving with the goal of entering.

(All that said, I am approaching this as a modern American English speaker, so it is possible I am misinterpreting something in these texts.)

0

In the sentence

Then I spurred on my animal, striving so to forget the world, my fears, and more than all, myself . .

the narrator is attempting to forget the world (and the other things) by means of spurring on the animal (I presume a horse).

The phrase

...he duty and the privilege of striving so to enter into sympathy with Him in his agony . . . "

means that the worshipers will be able to "enter into sympathy with Him" by means of striving. It does not say "striving to do what". In context this would mean "striving to live properly" or "striving to live a godly life" or something of the sort.

Note that Frankenstein by Mary Shelley is not exactly a recent book, and it uses forms now uncommon or obsolete. Indeed its language was a trifle florid even for its time. There is nothing wrong with a learner reading such a work, but it is well to keep the time of writing in mind.

0
0

It seems to me that you are right that it means "so as to" or "in order to".

There is some support for this in the Oxford English Dictionary, under "so" 28.a.

so..., or so...as, so as, followed by an infinitive denoting result or consequence. The omission of as is now regarded as irregular.

By "so as", the OED means what we often call "so as to"; it regards it instead as "so as" followed by the full infinitive. Similarly, so... here is a reference to "so" followed by the full infinitive, i.e. "so ... to ...".

1709 J.Swift: He has been indeed so wise, to make no Objection against the Truth of my Predictions.

Today we would say "...so wise as to...".

However, you may object that "so + adj + to" is a different kettle of fish from "so to". The OED has citations here for "so as to" and "so adj to" but not for "so to". On the other hand the editors viewed the senses as sufficiently closely related to group them all under 28.a.

The most recent citation even for "so as to" is, at the time of writing, from the 19th century (the entry hasn't been fully updated since it was written in 1913 - I imagine that when the staff finally get to this, they will have access to a lot more information than was easily available back then).

1896 Law Times 100 488/1 To repair the drain so as to abate the nuisance complained of.

Regardless, it is difficult to see how "so to" could mean anything other than "so as to" in the Shelley quote.

Here:

Once again arose the voice of praise; and then followed an exhortation, full of affectionate earnestness, urging upon the disciples of Christ the duty and the privilege of striving so to enter into sympathy with Him in his agony . . .

It is a bit harder to be certain but I think that this too means "so as to": in other words, that Christ's disciples are being urged to strive to enter into "sympathy with Him in his agony". I don't quite understand this well enough to paraphrase, but that may be due to limited understanding of the relevant theology on my part.

The most obvious alternative interpretation would be to take "so" as a pure adverb (=in such a way), but "to" on its own would seem to carry much of the same meaning as "in order to" in this context, so I think the sentence would end up meaning much the same thing.

-1

They don’t form any special phrase together.

“So” means in that way or by that action.

“To” is part of the infinitive verb “to forget”.

2
  • But consider "Once again arose the voice of praise; and then followed an exhortation, full of affectionate earnestness, urging upon the disciples of Christ the duty and the privilege of striving so to enter into sympathy with Him in his agony . . . "
    – Apollyon
    Jul 29, 2020 at 4:45
  • In Shelley's sentence, there is the action of spurring on the animal that designates the "in that way or by that action" as you suggested. However, in this most recent quote, there is no such action mentioned.
    – Apollyon
    Jul 29, 2020 at 4:47

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .