0

I am curious if study can be followed by a gerund or a infinitive or both?

  1. I studied to be a doctor :)
  2. I studied to pass the test :)
  3. I studied to ... (hard to think of examples)
  4. I studied playing the piano for years (seems odd to me)
  5. I studied reading and writing in class (these seem more like nouns than gerunds)
  6. I studied speaking Japanese with Taro (sounds weird to me)

Any thoughts?

0

The infinitives give the purpose of the studying, and and can be paraphrased with "in order to"

I studied [in order] to be a doctor.

I studied [in order] to pass the test.

The infinitive phrases are not the object of the verb "study" but form an adverbial modifier. Above the object is implied, but you could give a noun as the object.

I studied calculus to past the test.

On the other hand the gerund form is the object and tells us what you are studing:

I studied being a doctor (I investigated what life is like for doctors, slighly odd)

Other examples sound odd because you don't "study", you "practise" or "learn"

I studied playing the piano (I investigated how a pianist plays)

I practised playing the piano

But there is no reason that you can't use a gerund, but it is unusual to study a verbal action, normally you study a subject at school, or a thing.

For my PhD, I studied rodents making nests.

I think your confusing might come from a slightly different meaning of the word "study" in Engish and your language. In English it means "to investigate in detail" or "Acquire knowledge of a particular subject". So "study playing the piano" doesn't mean "learn to play the piano" but it means "investigate the playing action in detail."

| improve this answer | |
  • I think it's better to say that verbs like "study" and "practise" are catenative verbs taking gerund-participial clauses as complement (not object). "Playing the piano", for example, would then be the catenative complement of "studied / practised". – BillJ Aug 3 at 8:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.