1

In the sentence “I went jogging” am I correct in thinking “went” is the verb? And jogging a gerund?

In the sentence “David jogs for a mile every day” Jogs is the verb?

In the sentence “David had jogged yesterday” Had and jogged are both verbs

3
  • I'd say that "jogging" is also a verb in your first example. "I went jogging in the park yesterday".
    – BillJ
    Aug 7 '20 at 17:47
  • 1
    I went jogging is no different in construction than I like swimming. In the latter, swimming is normally considered to be a gerund; as such, so should be jogging. (Whether or not you believe it's functioning as a verb or an noun, or what terminology you apply to it, is something different.) Aug 7 '20 at 17:56
  • 1
    There is a difference, @Jason. In standard English, "I like that store" works, but "I went that store" doesn't. The verb to go doesn't take a direct object. The role of "jogging" in the first sentence is more like the role of a complete prepositional phrase, parallel to "I went to that store" or "I went by such a method" or "I went for that purpose." If we're making a distinction between participle and gerund, this "jogging" doesn't fill a gerund-like role. Aug 7 '20 at 19:09
0

Your examples, rearranged to put the two easier ones first:

2 "David jogs for a mile every day”
Yes, "jogs" is the verb.

3 “David had jogged yesterday”
"had jogged" is the verb "jog", conjugated as past perfect.
The verb "had" is an auxiliary, and it doesn't have a separate meaning; it just marks the past perfect.

1 “I went jogging”
You can consider "went jogging" a verb.

The following text calls this usage one example, among others, of "verb + participle":
Oxford Guide to English Grammar, John Eastman
Oxford "go/come + participle"

138 Verb + participle
(2) We use go/come + active participle to talk about some activities away from the home, especially leisure activities.
I'd love to go swimming.
We went riding yesterday.
Come cycling with us.
Mac goes jogging every morning.

(The entire quotation is not available online).

This text calls it "verb + -ing":
Collins Cobuild "v -ing"
I.4 The 'go riding' group
These verbs are concerned with taking part in an activity, often shopping or a leisure activity.
The next afternoon Amy went riding with Gerald.

It may be worth pointing out that "verb + participle" or "verb + ing" forms may vary significantly. Compare these sentences:
I went running. The main meaning is in "running", and "went" just means that I left home to do it.
I came running. In that sentence, the main meaning is in "came", and "running" is more of an adverb. (For example, "When she called, I came running.")

0

[1] I went jogging.

[2] David jogs for a mile every day.

[3] David had jogged yesterday.

In [1] "jogging" is undoubtedly a verb. The verb "go" is called a catenative verb because it takes non-finite gerund-participial clauses as complement. Here "went" has the clause "jogging" as complement. We know that "jogging" can't be a noun (your gerund) since "go" is intransitive, i.e. it's not possible to replace "jogging" with a 'real' noun (we can't say *I went shops" or *"I went Paris") etc.

In [2] "jogs" is clearly a verb, and in [3] "had jogged" is a perfect construction with the auxiliary verb "had" and the past participle verb "jogged".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.