Cake Wars is a game where fifteen participants are given sixty minutes to decorate a cake to a theme, after which the finished cakes are rated.

If the finished cakes are rated by the game's participants, then can I change "rated" to "contested" and is it better to do so?

  • 5
    Note about the title: "Substitute [X] for [Y]" means "replace [Y] with [X]," not the other way around.
    – Kevin
    Nov 8, 2020 at 0:07
  • 2
    Did you even look up the word "contested"? If so, what about the definition left you confused about whether or not it works in this case?
    – Kat
    Nov 8, 2020 at 1:30

2 Answers 2


"Contested" means to be disputed and ultimately challenged, so I would not use that word there. The game itself is a contest, however, so you could incorporate that word instead:

Cake Wars is a contest between fifteen bakers who are given sixty minutes and a theme to make a cake.

The use of the word "contest" affords us the opportunity to shorthand this a bit and omit obvious things like scoring the cakes and awarding a winner which are part and parcel of contests.

To better understand how "contested" would be used, consider this:

The results of the game were contested by Michael, who felt the winner did not play by the rules.


No. The word has a different meaning, and you should check the dictionary for the meaning of the adjective "contested", or the related verb "(to) contest".

If I "rate" a cake, then I judge how good, or bad, it is.

If I "contest" a cake... it doesn't have a normal meaning: Either I question it's correctness (??) "I contested my teacher's rule banning red socks"... That doesn't make sense.... or I strive to maintain control of the cake. That just about makes sense: "The twins were contesting the birthday cake, each claiming that to have the right to a larger slice".

In your context, it doesn't make sense at all. "To contest" never means "to rate".

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .