1

Could you tell me whether I have to use a or the before victim in the folliwing sentence?

Sara has been a/the victim of identity theft too.

What I'm trying to say is that Sara has been one of many people who fell victim to identity theft, not some specific victim. Logically the use of a should work there, but I've seen the used time and time again even though it was clear that specificity wasn't implied. Which one is more natural and correct to use in my example: a or the?

1

I have seen both used in an instance like this but I believe that "a" would work better than "the". Also, if I knew more about the situation then I maybe could understand their wording a little more but I will just go off of the sentence you gave me.

Sara has been the victim of identity theft too.

Sara is not the only one who has had her identity stolen so this would not work since "the" is implying that she been the victim of a specific person. It would work better if the sentence was "Sara has been the victim of an identity thief" since she was the specific victim of this specific person. She clearly has not since there is the word "too" at the end, meaning that she has not been the only victim of this crime.

Sara has been a victim of identity theft too.

This is more correct, or at least, more common from what I can tell. Since Sara is not the only person to have had their identity stolen the word "a" would imply that she has not been a specific victim.

Now, the area where they used "the" instead of "a" could be the reason for their wording because I do not know how other places tend to word their sentences.

0

I would say "a victim" since you're talking about multiple people falling victim to identity theft.

By the way, "natural" and "correct" are two different things. Sometimes, the "correct" way sounds extremely unnatural. English is a weird language.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.