0

I can't seem to get started today

If we read from the left to the right then we consecutively get following equals:

I can't (to do smth)

where "to do smth" is "seem to get started today"

But "seem to get started today" = "seem as if I get started today". So, we have:

I can't seem as if I get started today

And finally after substitute "I can't"="I am not able to" we have:

(Meaning 1): I am not able to seem as if I get started today

But It is wrong and the right meaning is:

(Meaning 2): I seem to not be able to get started today

Why is that?

2
  • You need to explain why you think the plain left-to-right reading is meaning 1. That isn't the case. – Daniel Roseman Nov 22 '20 at 11:22
  • Sorry, I have added information explaining why the plain left-to-right reading is meaning 1 to my question. – xyz Nov 22 '20 at 12:03
1

I can't seem to get started today

I agree with all of your logic.

On the face of it, the above means "I am unable to seem X". This implies that I am trying to seem X but for some reason I cannot.

However the meaning that a native speaker will understand is not based on logic but on expected meaning and common usage.

So the intention of the phrase is "It seems that I can't get started today."

You can consider this as an idiom that does not stand up to logical scrutiny. The intended meaning overrides the grammar.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.