0

Take a look at this sentence here:

He'd just been born with that harelip.

I am confused. "He had been" is past perfect continuous but for that born it should've been present participle. Is it then passive voice for past perfect tense? If yes then how because the subject "he" is still the subject.

1

You are right - 'had been' usually denotes past perfect continuous.

However, it is sometimes used in place of 'was', when referring to a single event (in this case a birth) which cannot be continuing into the present.

"He'd been born with that harelip" means the same as "He was born with that harelip".

The inclusion of the word "just" probably doesn't help - "just been" can mean something has happened only moments ago. For example, you could say a newborn baby had "just been born". However, another usage of 'just' is to mean "nothing more than", and in your example, I would guess that the wider context of the quote involved some talk over why someone's lip is the way it is now and they are in effect saying that he was born that way, and the answer is nothing more complicated than that.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.