0

No one, not even the doctors, think you're in trouble health-wise.

No one, not even the doctors, thinks you're in trouble health-wise.

Is the first sentence grammatically incorrect because the verb think doesn't go with the "no one" preceding the first comma? Or are both sentences right? Or is it the second one that's grammatically incorrect?

1
  • 1
    If you turn it round, you can see why the singular is required: No one thinks you're in trouble health-wise, not even the doctors. Jan 8 at 22:56
1

The sentence is awkward.

Drop “even the doctors,” and you get

No one thinks

which is obviously correct and idiomatic. “No one” is the subject and is singular.

When we add in “even the doctors,” we introduce a plural aspect that may suggest a plural verb. This is a grammatical mistake even though such mixtures of singular and plural fool even native speakers.

This mixing of singular and plural ideas is what makes the sentence awkward. Does it really mean much if the man who mows the lawn thinks you are healthy or ill. Surely what is important is what trained doctors think. What expresses the essence of the thought is

Not one doctor who examined you thinks you are ill.

There is no temptation to use a plural verb, and the thought is not encumbered with the irrelevancy of whether the mailman agrees or disagrees with those doctors.

This is another example that careless thought, or more usually hasty speech, induces grammatical error.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.