0

What's the difference between:

  1. "There are 23068 active users, 200 of whom are invisible"
  1. "There are 23068 active users, 200 out of whom are invisible"

I'm asking this because I can say for example:

  1. "Out of this group, there are 3 people who didn't show up"

if I can use "out of" like that, does it mean that those two mean the same?

0

1 Answer 1

-2

"There are 23068 users active, 200 of whom are invisible."

A non-defining relative clause with "of which" and "of whom" after quantifiers or numbers can be interpreted in this way. The above sentence containing a relative cause can be rewritten as:

"There are 23068 users active. 200 of them are invisible."

The phrase of whom defines the function of selecting a particular quantity in itself, hence there is no need whatsoever of using the extra word 'out'. It is uncommon, but not unheard of. However it means the same as the former expression 'of whom'.

Even GoogleNgram has very low entries of 'out of whom'.

Now your third sentence uses the phrase out of [anything] at the beginning. This structure is heard of. It would mean, from within their group there are three who didn't show up. It is actually similar to the previous sentences.

You can slightly reframe the sentence to mean and convey the same thing:

Out of the expected people in this group, 3 of them didn't show up/turn up.

But at the same time you can also write this sentence in terms of the above mentioned phrase.

There are 10 people in this group, 3 of whom didn't show up.

4
  • but you can say 1 out of 10, if so can't you use it for a group?
    – coolguy
    Jan 11, 2021 at 18:45
  • read the last meaning it says "from among a group or a particular number:"
    – coolguy
    Jan 11, 2021 at 18:48
  • @coolguy Yeah I know. But if ten people do form a group or already belong in one, I don't see what is wrong in saying that. Now if you are asking whether "1 out of 10 people didn't show up" is correct then it is. I never said it was wrong. You can insert the word 'group' and it will still work just fine. Let me know if I misunderstood you. Jan 11, 2021 at 19:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .