1

Is it good to say:

My family has/consist of 4 members/people.

Or much better to say:

There are 4 people/members in my family.

Maybe the first version is more official and the second one is everyday version?

Also, why it's necessary to use "me" (not "I") in the example:

There are 4 people in my family: my father, mother, sister and me.

1
  • Usually the number is not important unless it's a family of 10 and you really want to stress that... Jan 15 at 2:14
2

Neither is very common, except in speeches given by people learning English.

"There are four people in my family." is a simple and correct expression.

It is probably more common, if you are asked to talk about your family, to describe them:

Some families are simple

Tell me about your family

There's my wife and we have three children

You don't need to say "five people" because we can count.

On the other hand, some are more complex

Tell me about your family.

Well I live with my girlfriend and we have three kids, but the eldest is at university, Katy, my stepdaughter is at high school and the youngest, Jake, is still a baby. Also my girlfriend's mother lives in the annexe.

Families are complex: consider the example. How many people are in that family?

It would normally be "me" because that word is not the subject of a clause. In this respect, English is different from some other languages (in particular Latin and some Latin derived languages). There is some flexibility on this. "It is me." is normal and correct. "It is I" is also correct, but less used. In a long phrase "My mother, my father, my sister and I" could also be correct, but unnusual. English tends to reserve "I" for first-person singular subjects.

2
  • What about my last question?
    – Sergey
    Jan 15 at 7:31
  • Edited. The phrase isn't clearly the subject of a verb, so not usually "I"
    – James K
    Jan 15 at 9:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.