0

What's the difference between a limited duration, a temporary action and the current trend?

  1. "She is learning English." (Limited and temporary)

  2. "She is working in a bank." (Meaning temporarily but isn't it also limted?)

  3. "They are living in poverty.' (current trend as one of my books says)

Does the first sentence express a limited duration and isn't it also a temporary action? Does the third sentence express the current trend only?

"The current trend" was mentioned in my book "English Grammar in Context" by Michael Vince.

4
  • 1
    Can you give more details (ideally, a link) regarding current trend as one of my books says? Perhaps you misunderstood something there. Living in poverty isn't a "trend", so it makes no sense logically, and I can't imagine what aspect of grammar / semantics the writer is getting at there. – FumbleFingers Feb 16 at 13:25
  • 1
    It may be a reference to "current trend" in the sense of a current tendency. "They are getting poorer" would be a legitimate example. (Not so much "They are living in poverty", which is a temporary state rather than a tendency.) – rjpond Feb 16 at 14:09
  • The book calls it a trend. It gives these sentences: "Some kids are carrying more than 25 % of their body weight... which is giving them serious backache." It says both the present simple and progressive are correct when we are talking about a current trend and activity. I listed the definitions from my books. I didn't want to frame them in these categories. If I understand correctly a current activity and a temporary action and limited duration mean the same thing but a current trend is another thing. – Antonia A Feb 16 at 16:44
  • If the present simple and progressive are both correct when we describe current trends and current activities, are they interchangeable when we are talking about a limited duration and temporary actions? – Antonia A Feb 16 at 16:47
2

It is easy to understand the notional differences between:

A limited duration - a specified period, generally in which to complete an action or process.
A temporary action - an action that starts and stops, as opposed to one that continues indefinitely.
A current trend - a popular activity, fashion or similar.

However, it it not easy to define what is signified by temporary and permanent in your sentences.

One can learn English for a short time, a long time or the whole of one's life.
A job in a bank can be temporary or permanent.
Living in poverty is a state rather than a trend.
Insofar as trends are limited by definition to certain periods and poverty has been with humanity through-out recorded history, I certainly wouldn't call it a trend.

The question is why you wish to frame these actions/states in these categories. They are matters of interpretation.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.