0

Hello distinguished friends,

I've come across a word with which I am unfamiliar. Without further ado, I am putting the text:

It is perhaps risky to begin a paper by suggesting a possible change of title, particularly if the suggested change approximates a reversal of the original. This may seem flippant. The risk, however, is worth taking, the purpose being to press home a point.

My issue is centered on the last part which is "the purpose being...". As far as I am concerned, the author intends to say sort of this: "However, the risk is worth taking with the purpose of emphasizing a point".

So, these are my questions:

1- Is what I understand is right? If not, what is the right meaning?

2- If it is right, what kind of usage is this? It looks strange to me. And could I use like this way: "I don't want to go out with you, the purpose being to study for my exams"

Just in case, I put the meaning of confusing -at least for me- words:

flippant: not being serious about something that other people think you should be serious about

home press: make clear by special emphasis and try to convince somebody of something. f.e. They're trying to press home their message.

Thanks a bunch.

5
  • 1
    the purpose being to = the purpose is to x – Lambie Mar 1 at 23:43
  • 1
    You understood it almost correctly. This might be more idiomatic: "However, the risk is worth taking in order to emphasize a point". – Old Brixtonian Mar 2 at 4:00
  • 1
    Thank both of you for the comments guys! Because of time zone differences, I am replying a little bit late. And I remember you Old Brixtonian, we've talked before:) I hope you are fine :) – grammarian Mar 2 at 8:24
  • 1
    @grammerian You're welcome. We have. I am and I hope you are. Your questions are always interesting. – Old Brixtonian Mar 5 at 2:24
  • Thank you Brixtonian. I am good as well. I am trying to ask questions that are not mentioned in grammar books so that it may be helpful for others :D – grammarian Mar 7 at 22:07
1

I don't want to go out with you, the purpose being to study for my exams.

You couldn’t really use it like this, as it’s a negative/something that you’re not doing/doesn’t exist, so it can’t really have a purpose.

You could say:

I’ll be staying home instead of going out with you, the purpose being to study for my exams.

I’ll be honest, it’s not a phrase I particularly like, not least because the same thing could be said in much simpler ways.

Also, whose purpose is to press home a point? Changing a title? Taking a risk in and of itself? Though I understand the author’s intent, its not particularly clear to me from the wording without reading between the lines.

There is also further confusion:

It is perhaps risky to begin a paper by suggesting a possible change of title, particularly if the suggested change approximates a reversal of the original. This may seem flippant.

Two things are expressed:

  1. Changing a title.
  2. Changing a title which approximates a reversal of the original.

It’s not clear to me which one may supposedly seem flippant.

A much better expression (if they are intending to mean both) would be:

It may seem flippant.

Anyway, all in all, I take this paragraph to mean:

I’m changing the title, which may seem flippant, but it’s worth risking being seen as flippant because in changing the title I’m making a point.

2
  • Thank you Chris, for your answer. I also didn't like this usage. It seems this usage is a more formal way. As for confusions, I could say that what seems flippant is changing the title with a reversal of it. Because in the process of publishing it is a usual thing to change a title. But changing with the reversal is really weird. – grammarian Mar 2 at 8:36
  • Secondly, because changing the title equals taking the risk, for me, there is no exactly confusion. I mean the author will home press a point by taking the risk which is changing the title due to home press somethin. – grammarian Mar 2 at 8:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.