I'm an ESL teacher, and I'm having a difficult time deciding if these sentences are grammatically correct or natural:

  1. A: "What is fun for you?" B: "It is to play baseball."

  2. A: "What is the important thing to you?" B: "It is to play baseball."

I think the second one is more natural, but are they both grammatically correct? I would naturally use "playing" in both scenarios, so I'd gladly accept any opinions!

  • So your problem is "to play baseball" vs "playing baseball", right? Jun 10 at 7:28

Neither your questions, nor your answers, sound idiomatic.

The most natural would be:

Q. What do you do for fun?
A. I play baseball.

Your questions just don't sound natural, and the replies are unnecessarily formal, especially for a discussion about fun and baseball.


In both case A.'s I would say no they do not sound natural but I am English not American. I have played rounders but never baseball.

In both cases I would have thought a word indicating the amount of fun/pleasure would normally be added to the sentence. Also the topic is huge so we could be more specific.

A: "What game do you find most fun?" B: "Is it baseball?"

A: "What do you like most?" B: "Is it playing baseball?"

A: "Is playing baseball important to you?"

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.