0

After my research, I know that analogue (noun) means something similar to something else. Yet there are rare any discussion about "the analogue" and "an analogue".

I am not sure but they seem to imply different level of similarity between two things, IMHO.

When being preceded by "the", "the analogue" seems to imply something highly similar, or perhaps almost identical. On the other hand, an analogue refers to something with lower degree of similarity.

Could anyone please share your thoughts? Thank you very much for your time.

1
  • In my view it is only the usual difference between a and the. But perhaps there are situations where the existence of one very close analogue and the absence of others make it obvious which one you are talking about.
    – Peter
    Jul 30, 2021 at 9:41

2 Answers 2

1

The difference between a/an noun and the noun is simply the distinction between the generic noun (a dog) and a specific noun (the dog). So with analogue, we might imagine the following examples:

In poetry, water is often used as an analogue of redemption.

In Maya Angelou's poetry, water is repeatedly the analogue of redemption.

Comparing these sentences, it's easy to see that an analogue is generic, while the analogue refers to a specific or limited use.

(Disclaimer: I am using Maya Angelou's name as part of my illustration--I am unfamiliar with much of her poetry, so I have no idea if my example statement is true or false.)

1

The X means the speaker/writer thinks you should know which X he/she is talking about.

This is sometimes intentionally done when the speaker/writer knows you really don't know.

  • Sometimes this is malicious and is used for a speaker/writer to hold power over the listener/reader.

  • However other times it's used to signal to you that "the one X you should know about is coming up."

The analog to X is Y.

Speaker/writer is educating you. Speaker/writer believes there is just one Y that is the analog to X, or speaker/writer is saying this Y is what you need to be concerned with.

An analog to X is Y.

Speaker/writer is not educating you. There could be other Y's that are just as valid, and if you find out about other X's, you can use them.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .