5

Can an uncountable noun be an apposition of a countable noun?

For example,

A castle, sand, is desturcted.

It means a sand castle (a castle made of sand) is destructed.

1
  • 1
    Side note to your question: the normal word is "destroyed", not "destructed". I hesitate to say "destructed" isn't a word, but it's certainly not in every day use. (I'm afraid I don't understand your actual question, but maybe someone else does.)
    – IMSoP
    Sep 11 at 22:29
7

Yes, in principle, but not the examples you give.

You could say:

There was water, a puddle, on the floor.

It's a bit of an artificial example. But it is correct. Your example doesn't work. With apposition the sentence should "work" if you only use one of the nouns. So if I say "He lived in Paris, the capital of France" and I remove either "Paris" or "the capital of France" the meaning is the same.

But "the castle was destroyed" and "the sand was destroyed" have very different meanings. If you destroy the castle, the sand is still sand. So the apposition doesn't work.

(and was destroyed, not is destructed)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.