Today, I went to Rhyme's school and found a sentence...

You are being videoed

It's clear that this message is to warn people from misdoing something. A kinda "you are under surveillance".

But videoed? Oxford does not have it but the FreeDictionary does.

To me, this is a good use of that verb over "You are being recorded or observed".

What is the better way to write it if I want the same structure ... pronoun + verb + being + verb to convey the message?

Several dictionaries mention this, but of course not under the lemma videoed!

When you look (for instance at Oxford online) at the verb video, you will find this:

VERB (videos, videoing, videoed)

[WITH OBJECT] chiefly British

1 Make a video recording of (something broadcast on television):
how many programmes have you videoed and never managed to watch?

2 Film with a video camera:
he videoed our wedding

That said, many people will indeed frown at this. The usage is mentioned as chiefly British.
The issue with your alternatives is that you are being recorded may be interpreted as a sound recording being made (a recording studio usually records music, not film), and you are being observed means someone is watching, but no record of it may be created.

I have seen videotape being verbed (you are being videotaped), but I doubt that is a better alternative.

  • That's about the verb that some dictionaries mention. Now about the latter part of the question! – Maulik V Jul 25 '14 at 6:32
  • Sorry, I first reacted to your statement that Oxford did not have it - see my link ;) As for the latter part, now there it is :) – oerkelens Jul 25 '14 at 6:34
  • 2
    Videotape as a verb is just dandy in the US; I use it in project proposals every week. Tape is fine, too, but is subject to the same objection as record--it doesn't distinguish videotaping and audiotaping. On the ground we mostly say shoot, but in this context it would hardly do to say You are being shot! :) – StoneyB Jul 25 '14 at 11:43
  • @StoneyB You're being shot! would certainly corroborate some existing prejudices about the US of A... – oerkelens Jul 25 '14 at 11:45
  • It would certainly alarm the parents, though the kids would probably get a kick out of it. – StoneyB Jul 25 '14 at 11:48

This is an example of verbing a noun.

"You are being videoed" is equivalent to "You are being recorded on video" [or "...on closed-circuit television], in the same way that stating "this event is televised" means the same thing as "this event is being broadcast on television".

You can not express "you are being videoed" as "you are being verb", where verb is a single word and is not a verbed noun without losing part of the meaning. If you are ok with losing some of the intended meaning then I feel your suggestion "you are being recorded" is "best", though the expansion to include a phrase is better.

Your Answer

 
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.