1

From Oxford dictionary I have the first sentence. But from my grammar book is the following quote: "When the future event doesn't depend on the action described in the if-clause, we use be going to, not will." So, is it not better to use "will" in this example because there is a need for a clue?

I'm never going to guess the answer if you don't give me a clue.

I will never guess the answer if you don't give me a clue.

1 Answer 1

0

Generally speaking, be going to is the standard future tense of English. Almost everywhere you can use "will", or present continuous or simple present with future meaning, you could use be going to instead. Another way of thinking about this is, "To choose a future verb other than be going to, you need a good reason."

There are several future contexts where "will" is correct, but that doesn't mean only "will" is correct. Often, be going to is also correct.

This is one of the situations where be going to is also correct.

It's probably more common for people to use "will" in a context like this, but only because it's shorter. Both sound 100% natural.

2
  • Perhaps, in practice, there is no difference in meaning, as you say that but my grammar book (Cambridge University Press) says that "I'm going to open a bottle of limonade, if you want some." & "I'll open a bottle of limonade if you want some." have different meaning. "I'm going to open a bottle of limonade, if you want some." mean that I will open that bottle of limonade anyway.
    – Sergei
    Commented Oct 6, 2021 at 16:44
  • Your example about lemonade is one of the contexts I mentioned in my answer where you have a good reason to choose "will": you're making an offer. "Will" is used for making offers, but "be going to" usually isn't. Also, without the comma (only one of your examples has a comma), the "be going to" version could also mean "I'm only going to open the bottle if you want some."
    – gotube
    Commented Oct 6, 2021 at 21:45

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .