0

I have looked through many websites and know that when "any" is used as a determiner, it can be used with countable or uncountable nouns. I also read in my textbook that when "any" is used as part of the subject clause, it suggests restrictedness.

And so my question are,

  1. If "any" is used as a determiner in the subject clause, can it be used with different verb tenses, like perfect or perfect continuous?
  2. Why is example sentence #1 okay, but not sentences #2 and #3?

For example:

#1 Any of your questions CAN BE ASKED. (sentence okay)

#2 *Any of your questions HAVE BEEN ASKED. (present perfect 3rd person plural tense sentence not okay)

#3 *Any of your questions HAS BEEN ASKED. (present perfect 3rd person singular tense sentence not okay)

1
  • Number 2 would work if you said something like "I don't know if any of your questions HAVE BEEN ASKED." Any implies plural, though, which is why 3 won't work.
    – ralph.m
    Oct 13, 2021 at 23:32

1 Answer 1

1

Any has nothing to do with the verb, so tense is irrelevant. All of the following are acceptable, past present and future:

  • She didn't find any of the coins.
  • We don't find any problem with your work.
  • I won't have any time tomorrow to do that.

It is the logic of sentences 2 and 3 that are at fault. Since they're in the past, it is not any one question, but all of the questions that have been asked. In addition, #3 uses the wrong helper verb.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .