2

Somebody I am currently tutoring has the following question in a work book:

I was taught that Shakespeare ( ? ) in 1616

a) had died
b) died
c) has died
d) dies

The correct answer marked in the book is (b) "died". However, I am unsure of the reasoning. As far as I can tell "had died" and "died" (a and b) should both be grammatically correct and work in this context. But I was wondering how to explain why the book chose this over the other.

1
  • It wouldn't be particularly common, but it's perfectly okay to "backshift" to had died in your exact context (because you've already invoked the past with I was taught). Without that prior past tense context, as in - I know that Shakespeare had died in 1616, it would not be acceptable to use the Past Perfect form. Basically, your textbook isn't very good. Jan 25, 2022 at 12:45

1 Answer 1

2

I agree with you that both (a) and (b) are possible answers.

As a simple statement of fact, we would use (b). However, this sentence is a bit more complex. You could say "I always thought that Shakespeare had died in 1615, but my teacher says it was 1616."

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .