0

Is it 'in time' or 'on time' here?:

...

GERRARD: Hello. Yes, speaking. Sorry I can’t let you have the props in time for rehearsal...

It's from a story in which Gerrard talks over the phone to someone and says a specific time duration, which I infer from this:

GERRARD: ... Well, tell him to phone up directly. I must know ... Yes, I expect I’ll still be here, but you mustn’t count on that ... In about ten minutes’ time. Right-ho. Goodbye.

This is the story where the line is.

From this, can I say that the "in time" here is correct too, or is 'on time' the correct phrase to be used in the sentence? My point is that, since a specific time is mentioned, from so-to-so, 'in time' should be correct. Or, should it be something like "in this time" or "in the time" where 'this' and 'the' refer to the time interval?

If I'm not wrong, 'on time' is usually used when the task is completed at the brink of the moment. As the meaning is decided by the author, I only say that it either would be either 'in time' or 'in <pronoun/word referring to the time interval> time' as when such a phrase is used, it usually means/refers to "between (time1 and time2)"/"in the time of (time2-time1)", time1 and time2 (in this case, the then-current time and that + 10 minutes) being mentioned earlier, and its meaning is/can be totally different from on time's.

I know that there are many grammatical errors in the sentences, but the question is the title.

Please correct me if I'm wrong; I hope this makes sense.

11
  • 3
    If something happens 'on time' that means it happened at the time when it was scheduled to happen (it's very strongly implied that there is a specific pre-planned time for it to happen). But something can happen 'in time' even if there was no specific scheduled time involved - that just means it didn't happen too late (for something else to also happen, be prevented from happening, or whatever). But that in/on time distinction is irrelevant to expressions like in ten minutes time (ten minutes from now), which never involve preposition on. Feb 26, 2022 at 15:05
  • 1
    So... are you asking about the difference between We arrived on/in time for the concert, or We will leave in five minutes time? Feb 26, 2022 at 15:07
  • 1
    Gerrard cannot let the caller have the stage props in time for the rehearsal, that is, by the time it is scheduled to begin. Feb 26, 2022 at 17:24
  • 2
    Do you mean "Is in time used correctly in the quotation?" Yes - I told you in my earlier comment what it means. The props could only be delivered at a time that was too late for the rehearsal. Feb 27, 2022 at 15:04
  • 2
    As far as I know (and as we have all tried to explain), 'on time' only means 'punctually, at the appointed time'. Feb 27, 2022 at 16:11

0

You must log in to answer this question.