1

There is a text: "Will you give me the article after you (write) you homework." I would like to know, what is better to put: will have written or have written?

1
  • 2
    When you say "There is a text", do you mean that you wrote this sentence or that you found it somewhere? A native speaker would say ...when you have done your homework. May 27, 2022 at 12:04

2 Answers 2

1

To answer what I think is your main question: native English speakers hardly ever use the modal "will" (often misleadingly referred to as "the future tense") in temporal clauses (introduced by expressions such as "when", "after", "before").

So after you will have written is not idiomatic - in any context as far as I can think. After you have written is OK, but as another reply says After you finish is even more normal.

0

There are problems with your sentence. What do you want to say? If it is a question it needs a question mark at the end. If it is an instruction you don't need "will you."

[In the UK:] As Kate Bunting said, children do their homework: they don't write it. We say, "...after you've done your homework" or, more commonly, "...when you've done your homework."

If the child has already started doing his/her homework we might say, "...when you've finished your homework."

If the 'article' refers to the homework, we might ask, "Will you give me your homework when you've done/finished it?"

If the homework is to write an article (for the school magazine, perhaps) then we might ask, "Will you give me the article when you've written it?"

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .