7

If someone is asked the question below,

Q: Do you work or are you a student?
A: Neither. I had a job couple of months ago, but I lost it because...

does this answer above sound correct?

  • 2
    That’s like asking “Are you married, or do you have a job instead?” – tchrist Feb 28 '13 at 13:27
  • Nope. In fact these two options are relevant, especially when you can not know from his/her appearance. – canoe Feb 28 '13 at 13:39
  • 3
    What a strange question. I'm halfway through my Software Engineering degree and part of my study is to work for a year, on an industrial placement. I would say both here :^) To be more on topic, the answer sounds as right as it could be, as strange/rude as the question sounds... – Felix Weir Feb 28 '13 at 14:16
  • 2
    One could work and be a student. One could be unemployed and not be a student. One could be retired. One could be a housewife. For that matter, being a student might involve work, but that's probably just being contrary: we know what the questioner meant by "work". Of course real life is full of questions like this with debateable assumptions. "Are you a member of my political party or are you a racist?" etc – Jay Feb 28 '13 at 16:19
  • 3
    I think a better way to ask this question would be "Do you have a full-time job, or are you a full-time student?" (In the U.S., a full-time job is usually 40 hours a week, and a full-time student takes at least 12 credit hours of coursework.) Many full-time students have part-time jobs, and many full-time workers are part-time students, but you don't find too many people who work full time while they are full-time students. – J.R. Feb 28 '13 at 20:07
10

As much as the question might have some implications (i.e. it implies that someone can't work and be a student at the same time - which is not true), the answer sounds correct, according to the definition of neither.

1

My 2¢:

  • If you’re talking with somebody who needs the information (or whom you want to tell), such as a biographer or a prospective employer, the answer you suggested is just about right.
  • For pretty much anybody else, the conventional response is, “I’m between jobs right now.”  You can elaborate if asked (but see the next bullet).
  • OR, you can just find some way of saying that you find the question inappropriately intrusive.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.