1

When it is a statement about a habit, a regular event, or things like that, what tense do we use in a noun clause: simple past or present perfect?

Example 1

Whenever I am taking notes, I write down what the teacher taught.

Example 2

Whenever I am taking notes, I write down what the teacher has taught.

In my view: I guess both are acceptable, but British English speakers might think it is better to use present perfect because they tend to perceive simple past is a single past event. However, I am not sure. Can anyone shed light on this topic?

2
  • Do you mean that you often take notes and those times you write down what the teacher taught? Oct 14, 2023 at 10:31
  • Is teaching, is best here.
    – Lambie
    Oct 14, 2023 at 13:36

2 Answers 2

0

You use present simple to describe current habitual activities:

Whenever I take notes, I write down what the teacher teaches.

You would only use a past tense to describe a past (and no longer current) habitual action:

Whenever I took notes, I wrote down what the teacher taught.

You would only use present perfect if the writing occurs after the teaching:

At the end of each day, I write down everything that the teacher has taught that day.

0

Both are acceptable, but the present perfect is defter, as typically notes are written down soon after a teacher has uttered something noteworthy, not long after. You are describing your practice of taking notes while the utterance is still "fresh".

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .