0

Is it right to use will after some time expressions?

I thought you couldn't use will after before, after...

Both sentences below are right but will on the second would be wrong. Or is the first one wrong?

  1. Before the app will work, you have to set it up on the website.

  2. Clean your room before your father gets home.

1 Answer 1

1

Often, before NP will VP means, essentially, Otherwise, NP won’t VP. “You must finish your vegetables before your mother will give you dessert.” In such cases, before isn’t entirely temporal, but also a fair bit logical.

2
  • This exactly. "You must finish your vegetables before your mother gives you dessert" is a wholly temporal link, she will give you dessert regardless. Nov 24, 2023 at 4:58
  • No, @the-baby-is-you, not in my idiolect anyway. For me, it carries a strong sense of, “Don’t imagine you’ll get dessert without finishing your vegetables.” It is not parallel to When you’ve finished your ice cream we can go to the park where both the activity currently in progress (eating ice cream) and it’s promised successor (going to the park) are desired by the addressee. The first example’s connotation includes “It doesn’t matter how distasteful you find the prospect of completing the precondition (finishing your vegetables), it remains a precondition that we will enforce.” Nov 24, 2023 at 11:55

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .