0

At the age of thirteen, after receiving a call, she would join 'The sisters of Charity'.

How is 'would' used here? It could have been written:

At the age of thirteen, after receiving a call, she joined 'The sisters of Charity'.

First off, is this a correct sentence? I heard it from a documentary.

Thanks brp7

2
  • Yes, she would join... is effectively a stylised "literary device" equivalent to she joined... (more precisely, she went on to join...). You wouldn't normally use anything like that in a spoken conversational context. Commented Jul 11 at 16:02
  • This documentary is probably about - Mother Theresa. (Sisters of charity) Commented Jul 11 at 18:10

2 Answers 2

2

You don't say who the documentary was about. I assume that this sentence follows some information about the subject's earlier childhood. At that time, her joining the Sisters was still in the future.

This is a fairly common usage when telling someone's life story.

At school, he met the girl who would later become his wife.

(When they were at school together, their marriage was, of course, some years in the future.)

2

Yes, "would" has several functions: it can be used for conditional clause, it can be used for past habits, and it can be used for "future in the past".

In this example the context makes the interpretation unambiguous. It can't be a conditional (since there is no condition explicit or implied). It can't be a past habit unless you think that joining a nunnery could be a "habit" (pun intended). So it must be "future in the past". That is from the perspective of the narrative, which is set just after the time of the "call", the act of joining the sisters of mercy is in the future. At that time you'd say "She is thirteen and she just received a call, and she will join the sisters of charity." That is the future tense. So when reporting it as a past it becomes "she would join..."

It wouldn't be wrong to say "After receiving a call she joined ..." since it is also "in the past" as well as being in the future of the past.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .