Which of the following sentences are grammatically correct? Which ones are formal, idiomatic and proper to use in writing an essay?

  • What makes for a good job?
  • What makes a good job?
  • What does make a good job?
  • What does make for a good job?
  • 1
    Sentence 1 is definitely preferred idiomatically. I can invent limited circumstances in which each of the other 3 would make sense, but they are quite restricted. "make for" is not a particularly formal idiom but could be used without causing comment in a formal setting. "Contributes to" or "produces" might work better in writing. A completely different sentence structure might be better still. "What are the qualities of a good job?" Nov 6 '14 at 18:40
  • @JasonPatterson Thank you and Omnidisciplinarianist for your answer. To be frank my question is not answered yet in the sense for which I'm looking. I wonder if these sentences are in "Present simple" tense, which I believe they are, why shouldn't we use an auxiliary verb?
    – mok
    Nov 6 '14 at 19:59
  • 1
    You can use one to set the tense, but we don't need an auxiliary verb for linking verbs in the present simple tense, generally speaking. For a clearer example, we say "What is your name?", not "What does be your name?" "To make for" is used in the same sense in your sentence that "to be" is in mine. In fact, we could substitute "is" in place of "makes for" and get a sentence with a very similar meaning. Nov 7 '14 at 4:41
  • With the word does, I expect it to be emphasized, and used as a follow up. Imagine this: Person 1) "Long hours and uncomfortable environment don't make for a good job." Person 2) "What does make for a good job?"
    – TecBrat
    Jan 19 '17 at 5:04

To answer the questions you ask:

  1. Which of the following sentences are grammatically correct? The first two.
  2. Which ones are formal, idiomatic and proper to use in writing an essay? Again, the first two.

However, there's a question that hasn't been asked that should also be answered: "What's the difference between makes and makes for then?"

The phrase makes for has a more specific meaning that the word makes and in this context limits its definition to the following:

  • to help maintain or promote; further
  • to have or produce a particular effect or result

Asking "what makes for a good job?" is asking what causes (as a result) a job to be good and what maintains that goodness. Asking "what makes a good job?" expands the question to encompass its creation, development, composition, and so on.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.