4

"John threw Mama from the train a kiss." This statement is used as an example of poor syntax. It sounds as if John threw Mama off the train, followed by a kiss. How would one arrange this statement into a syntax that expresses John's action correctly?

5

This is a joke, whose reference is to the syntax of German-speaking immigrants.

Throw papa down the stairs his hat.

From the train, John threw a kiss to mama.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    Cool, never heard about that. It turns out there was even a song "Mama From The Train". Not to mention the movie with DeVito. – CowperKettle Nov 14 '14 at 16:45
  • 1
    @CopperKettle Great link! Loved the line, "Don't leave her hungry behind." – JimM Nov 14 '14 at 20:01
  • 1
    @CopperKettle: Some of us live in Pennsylvania and know all kinds of cool things about the so-called "Pennsylvania Dutch" :-) Since we're talking about a movie here, I'll recommend Peter Weir's film, Witness. – Tᴚoɯɐuo Nov 15 '14 at 10:42
2

You can rearrange the words, or change the words (as one answer does) to make many different sentences with non-poor syntax.

The question is What do you want the sentence to mean?

When you know that, you can rightly order the words

Since John is the one doing the action, per the last sentence of the OP, then my favorite is

John threw the train a kiss from Mama.

| improve this answer | |
  • Fruit flies like a banana. – bmargulies Nov 14 '14 at 17:23
1

John threw a kiss to his mama/mother on the train.

Assuming this isn't a reference to the movie, "Throw Mama from the Train"

Throw a kiss <-- generally means to kiss the palm of your hand and figuratively toss it to the recipient.

Looking at TRomanos answer and rereading the OP's sentence, it is a bit ambiguous who is on the train because of the syntax. To me, it looks as though Mama is on the train. "...Mama from the train..." and your follow up statement, "It sounds as if John threw Mama off the train" makes me believe so.

Where TRomano's answer suggests that John is on the train. "From the train, John threw a kiss to mama."

| improve this answer | |
  • Good point about the ambiguity of whether John or Mama was on the train. I had assumed John was on the train. – JimM Nov 14 '14 at 15:28
  • 1
    If Mama was on the train it would be "John threw Mama (who was) on the train a kiss.", which doesn't sound natural and everything (without the who was), but the 'from' construction is hardly ambiguous. – David Mulder Nov 14 '14 at 18:05
  • 1
    Given that the syntax is incorrect to begin with I don't think you can rightfully say that it is not ambiguous. Especially without punctuation. – David Nov 14 '14 at 18:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.