1

Having considered definition as to the following terms, could we always apply "precursor" instead of "pioneering"?

precursor (of/to something) (formal) a person or thing that comes before somebody/something similar and that leads to or influences its development : a stringed instrument that was the precursor of the guitar; events that were precursors to revolution

pioneering: introducing ideas and methods that have never been used before: pioneering work on infant mortality; the pioneering days of radio

Also, for precursor, when should you use "a precursor to" vs "a precursor of"? Is there a difference in meaning between the two?

Would you just explain the updated questions? UPDATED So, is the following correct? Captain Cook was the pioneer in the discovery of new lands.

And, could you differentiate any difference between pioneering and pioneer as a noun? –

  • precursor is a noun, and pioneering is an adjective, so you can't swap the two words for each other. But I think you're asking if something is a precursor, does that mean it was also pioneering (which is a more interesting question). – J.R. Dec 12 '14 at 8:44
  • Would that be the same as asking if a precursor would be the same as a pioneer? – miltonaut Dec 12 '14 at 9:15
  • Yes you are right – nima Dec 12 '14 at 11:19
  • My thinking is that precursor could be anything that preceded the thing in mind. My computer, for instance, has many precursors (the original PC and all of the subsequent generations of PCs up to this one). Pioneering, on the other hand, describes the first of something: think of Steve Jobs or Bill Gates and their work. – Melissa R Dec 12 '14 at 20:51
  • Also, for precursor, when should you use "a precursor to" vs "a precursor of"? Is there a difference in meaning between the two? – nima Dec 13 '14 at 7:22
1

Regarding "precursor" vs "pioneering": No, they are not interchangeable with regarding to meaning. A precursor is a relationship between two things. In your example, the "instrument" that came before the guitar is the precursor. However, if the guitar had never been invented, the "instrument" would not be a precursor. So, another definition could be: "This which led to that." No that = no this leading to it. Also, precursing isn't a word (until someone says it, I guess!) and it is most definitely not a verb. One does not precurse, unless you are about to swear, maybe. As well, precursor, the vast majority of time, does not refer to a specific person... I'm guessing because, outside of reproduction, this person does not lead to that person. Again, that's not a hard and fast rule, but one doesn't say, "Captain Cook was the precursor to the discovery of new lands," but instead, "Captain Cook's voyages were the precursor to the discovery of new lands."

Pioneer(ing) is a noun to indicate (usually) a person. It's not limited to that at all as a kangaroo can be a pioneer depending on the context. However, "It is a pioneer," does not ring as proper as, "She is a pioneer." Again, not to say it's not correct, but a pioneer is one who pioneers. It's a noun defined by a verb. One cannot be a pioneer unless they are pioneering. It's like saying one is a liar if one never lies. You have to lie to be a liar. You have to pioneer to be a pioneer.

That said, unless something can pioneer, it cannot be a pioneer. Perhaps a dinosaur pioneered onto the glacier, which would be correct, but a glacier cannot pioneer. It's personification.

Regarding the word, Pioneering, specifically, it does indicate relationship, but that of chronology, not of succession. Precursor is, "this, which led to that." Pioneering is, "they who did it first." The relationship is between "they/he/she" and whatever "it" is. So, "He set foot on the moon." But it must be the "first" or some similar relationship. So it's not a successive, "this came before that," but, "this was the first ever."

The precursor to the spaceship was the airplane whose precursor was the boat whose precursor was the wagon whose precursor was the foot. (I'm making that up, but you can see where I'm going with that, I hope).

However, the pioneer of the spaceship was not the airplane, nor was the airplane pioneering the spaceship. Astronaut X was the pioneer who flew the spaceship for the first time. Lewis and Clark pioneered the West.

Sorry, that was wordy but I hope it explains that these are not interchangeable words.

Regarding, "a precursor of," and, "a precursor to." They are interchangeable. As I mentioned "precursor" indicates relationship. Both of and to properly refer to "that" which followed.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.