2

I wonder whether I need the article in the sentence

"What is [the] statistics on traffic accidents?"

and also what article should I use in the second part of the title of this question.

  • 2
    Here I would have statistics are (plural) because it is about a collection of data. It is singular when designing the science. – Laure Dec 27 '14 at 10:42
  • @Laure how to see it is plural? In Russian the collection of data is "statistika" which is singular, similarly to the field... – Anixx Dec 27 '14 at 10:47
  • A related question at ELU. – CowperKettle Dec 27 '14 at 10:54
  • 1
    I expect this could be another question altogether. Compare the two sentences : 1) "Statistics is the science that studies collections of data." 2) "The statistics on road accidents involving children are a national tragedy. Sentence 1 am talking about the science that is an object of study (singular). Sentence 2 I am talking about a particular collection of data that is the object of my attention (plural). – Laure Dec 27 '14 at 10:56
4

What are the statistics on traffic accidents? (meaning: Please provide me with the necessary data)

Here, you would need to use the definite article, because the word statistics is postmodified by the prepositional phrase "on traffic accidents" which makes the reference definite.

What is statistics on traffic accidents? (meaning: I don't know what the phrase "statistics on traffic accidents" means)

Here, you would need no article, because you are not trying to get some specific data ("statistics") on some traffic accidents but rather to ascertain the meaning of the whole phrase "statistics on traffic accidents"). It could be that the phrase is used as a column header in a big table, and you need to know what exactly does it reflect.

Such a sentence would, however, need quotation marks to be fully understood in writing:

What is 'statistics on traffic accidents'?

The word statistics is a strange beast in English: a plural noun treated as singular.


Do I need the/an article here?

Since you've used the article the in your first sentence, placing it in square parentheses, the reader is aware what article you are referring to. Hence, it would be okay to use the in the question. In other words:

Do I need to use this article (which I put in the square brackets) here? (such will be the meaning with the)

But you can use an as well: this would imply that you are open to the possibility that it will be a that will suit your example sentence best. In other words:

Do I need to use any article here? (such will be the meaning with an)

  • 1
    Should not the later phrase use quotes, like 'What is "statistics on traffic accidents"?' and otherwise ungrammatical? – Anixx Dec 27 '14 at 10:49
  • Yes, @Anixx, I just wanted to add the mention that such a sentence would use quotation marks. – CowperKettle Dec 27 '14 at 10:52
  • What about the second part of the question? – Anixx Dec 27 '14 at 10:58
  • 1
    @Anixx - uno momento. (0: – CowperKettle Dec 27 '14 at 10:59
2

Since "statistics" is a plural noun, you need a plural verb. Yes, you need an article before statistics but not before traffic accidents. "What are the statistics on traffic accidents?" would be correct.

  • Why it is plural? – Anixx Dec 27 '14 at 10:46
0

"Statistics" is a plural noun; you can usually tell this about English nouns by seeing whether they end with -s and whether removing the -s yields another valid English noun. (Counterexample: princess.)

"Statistics", naturally, is the plural of "statistic". You might equally well ask "What is a statistic [just one statistic] about traffic accidents?", to which I might answer, "130 people died in traffic accidents in Chicago last year." That's certainly a statistic.

If you're asking for "the statistics", that has a connotation of asking for all the statistics that could possibly be relevant (to whatever it is we're talking about), or at least all the statistics that are currently available.

Google tells me that in Russian, the word for a single statistic might be "статистическая величина".


FYI, in English, statistic is also often used as a synonym for casualty (with the connotation of loss or unimportance of personal identity). In your original context, it wouldn't naturally be interpreted that way; but I could write

When her car crashed fatally into that telephone pole, Alice became yet another statistic in America's deadly love affair with the automobile.

This usage usually occurs on its own or with the preposition in, as opposed to the mathematical/statistical usage, which takes the preposition on.


Oh, and I should add: Statistics (as an uncountable mass noun) is the branch of mathematics that deals with statistics (plural). Compare: mathematics, logistics, arithmetic, logic. All of these are mass nouns referring to branches of mathematics. And yes, some of them take -s and some don't; it's pretty much random.

I could construct contexts in which the difference between count and mass nouns was pretty subtle:

Alice studies automobile statistics.
(Probably the count noun is meant: statistics about automobiles.)

Beth studies automotive statistics.
(Probably the mass noun: some sub-field of statistics.)

Carol studies financial statistics.
(Might plausibly be either one.)

but these aren't very important to your original question. You're unlikely to see anything like these in real life.

  • Interesting answer, @Quuxplusone! Especially the example with "statistic" in singular. There's a typo: "in" and "on" are prepositions, not articles. Do you think that the could be omitted in Anixx's example sentence? – CowperKettle Dec 27 '14 at 16:16
  • 1
    @CopperKettle: Fixed, thanks! No, I think "What are statistics on X?" isn't anything a native speaker would say. Heard aloud, I would most likely interpret it as asking for a definition of the phrase "statistics on X", rather than asking for examples of statistics on X. Heard aloud with a strong accent, I would interpret it as "What are the statistics on X?" where the non-native speaker accidentally dropped the the — but that's not the same as being idiomatic English. – Quuxplusone Dec 28 '14 at 3:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.