7

I want to know which sentence is correct. If i say

Guess, what it is?

or

Guess, what is it?

which one is correct?

migrated from english.stackexchange.com Jan 16 '15 at 11:09

This question came from our site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts.

3

Guess, what is it ?

I remove the punctuation for us to get all the possibilities and study each as I think this is the appropriate way to answer this question:

Guess what is it/ it is

Possibility 1: Single imperative sentence

The person might have ordered the audience; as if s/he is a teacher asking a question:

Guess what it is.

There's only one sentence and it's imperative.

Possibility 2: Single exclamation sentence

The speaker is apparently very emotionally intrigued. S/he wants to tell the audience about a piece of news that has exclaimed her.

Guess what it is!

On the other hand, this might come unusual to a native speaker as they usually omit (it is) and get:

Guess what!

Note that this is mainly a question, but since it's turned into an expression and it's exclaiming connotation is usually "heavier" than it's questioning connotation, we often see it with an exclamation mark.

Possibility 3: An imperative statement followed by a question

As Edwin mentions, a correct punctuation plays an important role on deciding what this statement means.

Guess, (or you can just put a dot or a colon) what is it?

As the title of the possibility describes, guess can act as another imperative sentence that has no relation to the following one. "What is it?" is the correct structure if you're asking a question.

So your first statement has to be "repunctuated". Otherwise, it can completely apply to possibility one.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.