3

I've looked them up on Dictionary.com, and it says that they are interchangeable. But, when I search it on Reference.com (accidentally), this comes up: disk vs. disc.

Now, the sites confuse me, as many sites say that they are interchangeable while others suggest that they have specific meanings.

So, are they different or not? Why are there 2 words for one thing, if they are interchangeable?

3

First off, I wouldn't lose any sleep over it. I imagine you could swap the two in almost any context and I doubt anyone (regardless of origin) would notice.

That said, for all meanings not concerning computers, "disc" is probably more common in British English, and "disk" in American English (that's the OED's take, and matches my experience), but use whichever you prefer. You might think disc would be older, since the word derives from the Latin discus, but there are some pretty old "disk" quotes listed in the OED (one from the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, 1665--so no American influence there).

For computers, I have to concede that the Apple page does have a point (though calling it a "distinct difference" is carrying it way too far towards prescription on what's clearly a descriptive issue--for that matter, so is devoting a support page to it). One pretty much always sees "compact disc". "Floppy disks" (for those that remember them) were sometimes called "diskettes"; which term came first, I don't know, but the association between the two probably caused the K spelling to stick. Personally, I would also spell "hard disk" with a K as well--since the term originated by analogy to "floppy disk", that makes sense. I don't think the optical/magnetic split between disc/disk is based on anything like logic, but it does seem to be the way things have developed (mostly: I'd still call a CD drive a disk drive). The OED even acknowledges this: "Some writers have used the spelling disk for magnetic ones (‘hard disk’, ‘floppy disk’), and disc for optical ones (‘compact disc’, ‘laser disc’).". But then, it also lists "compact disc (also disk)".

There might be some technical applications where one is used over the other, but it'll never be based on any logic, since the two words mean exactly the same thing, so if you run into that, just look around to see which is more common. ("Disc" brakes gets the wikipedia entry, but no one would wonder for a second what "disk brakes" were.)

As to why both exist: who knows? Both spellings have been around a long time, so it is surprising neither has died out (since there never seems to have been a difference in meaning between them, at least until Apple got involved). If I were to engage in rank speculation, I would wonder if "disc" didn't come into the language directly from Latin, while "disk" meandered in via the French disque.

0

All the while you've left out the vertebral discs of the spinal column. Because of this, I've always referred to CDs/DVDs/Floppies as DISKS, not discs.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.