13

In the following quote by Billy Sunday

Going to church doesn’t make you a Christian any more than going to a garage makes you an automobile.

Can anyone please explain/elaborate the usage and meaning of "any more than"?

10

The construction [not X] any more than [Y] is a way of comparing a primary negative assertion to an obviously absurd positive secondary assertion. The underlying logic is:

[X] is not any more true than [Y] … that is, it is equally untrue
[Going to church makes you a Christian] is not any more true than [going to a garage makes you a car].

Move the denial into the primary proposition, and you have:

[X is not true] any more than [Y]

Is not true reduces, in context, to VERBs not, so you end up with:

[Going to church doesn’t make you a Christian] any more than [going to a garage makes you a car].

  • amazing way of explaining – Vikram Apr 12 '13 at 13:30
8

This is merely a comparison of two things.

Doing A doesn't mean that you're an X. (church)
Doing B doesn't mean that you're a Y. (garage)
Therefore, A and B are equally ineffective measures of your true nature. OR
Therefore, your doing A doesn't tell us more about your true nature than your doing B does.

So both A and B have zero value as signs of your character and nature. They are equal.

Here's another example of the usage:

The distinction between a "formal" fallacy and a "material" fallacy is not fixed or clear--any more than that between "formal" and "material" logic.

In this case, what these two pairs of terms mean and how each member of a pair differs from its opposite is equally unclear and unfixed.

-1

"any more than" can be a substitute for "even if" for example. Going to church does not make you a Christian even if going to a garage makes you a car. The whole idea of the sentence is that while going to a garage does not make you a car, likewise going to a church does not necessarily make you a christian.

  • "...even if going to a garage makes you a car" implies that going to a garage DOES make you a car. "Any more than" means exactly the opposite. Going to a garage doesn't make you a car, and going to church doesn't make you a Christian. – ColleenV Oct 20 '17 at 11:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.